This year’s finale had a lot of emotion. For one, the legendary Simon Cowell will no longer judge the competition; the main voice of the panel giving criticism that made the show famous. I mean come on, who didn’t watch it to see who Simon would rip apart. I know I surely did.
This season also had a new judge, Ellen DeGeneres. A woman who undoubtedly loves music, and dances to a new song each and every weekday on her show. I thought she did alright for her first season. I noticed the first 24 she seemed to mimic Randy’s criticism a lot, almost to the word. I never really saw her disagree with Randy, except for one time with Tim. Was she the most qualified? Let’s see, Simon and Randy are two huge entities in the music recording field. Randy played bass with Journey, and Simon has produced some of the world’s top artists. Kara was a Grammy winning song writer and vocalist. Ellen? She loves music. Odd in many ways, but she did better than most thought.
The final episode of Season 9 didn’t have any gaudy lip-syncing, bikini flashes, or unnecessary hype. Instead it was filled with great performances by Janet Jackson, Cristina Aguilera, Joe Cocker, Alanis Morissette, Chicago, Michael McDonald, and amazingly enough, the very lucky Bret Michaels. It’s really what the show needed after last year’s debacle.
Season 9′s finalists were both chosen in Chicago. You had Lee DeWyze, and Crystal Bowersox. Each are completely different in sound and personality, but each knows exactly what recording artist they are. Both Crystal and Lee were good choices for this year’s finale, and I still say both were a MUCH better choice than last year. Over the past nine seasons, Idol has only given the world really four successful Idols, and five duds. Sure, they may have had a little success, but the runners-up in that year have surely out performed them. Reuben had some success, more than some, with most of it being in the gospel genre. Fantasia and Taylor Hicks were complete flops. It’s still a little too early yet, but I only heard Adam Lambert on the radio and nothing from Kris Allen. Would this year be different?
If I had to compare these finalists to anyone, I would say Lee was a good example of David Cook, and Danny Gokey from Season 8, whom he has a striking resemblance to. Crystal Bowersox would match well with the great Janis Joplin and sounded phenomenal in her duet with Alanis tonight. Sure, each one has their strengths and weaknesses, but either way, I would enjoy this year’s winner over last year’s.
In the end, Lee DeWyze won Season 9 despite a weak performance in the final contest, and not being consistent all season. He found his rhythm in the last few weeks which really was his saving grace. Crystal never was in the bottom three. She continued to blow the judges away week after week, and was the sure winner of this year, again another major upset. I don’t know if people voted for Lee because of his good looks, or just because he was the underdog. We’ll see if America picked them right, because on voting lately, America has let us all down majorly. I don’t want to see a sixth flop and Crystal outdoing Lee in the long run. I mean, the winner is supposed to be the best, the one that America is dying to see in the stores and will rush out to get their new release when the time comes. Somehow that never seems to happen unless your Carrie Underwood or Kelly Clarkson. Jordin Sparks has done well for herself, but not nearly as popular as those two.
Only time will tell, but I have a good feeling Idol will never be the same, and many will stop watching it next year. I have seen LOTS of disgust over the winner; they like him, but they know Crystal is the better of the two. There won’t be harsh criticism in there either unless Gordon Ramsay comes to judge Idol. I think the show is in the books. It will go down as one of the most popular reality shows in history, but like most, I won’t be watching next year unless they get one hell of a judge to replace Simon.
Congrats to Lee and Crystal. We wish you all the best on your future endeavors.










Social Networks